How is ankle fusion different from ankle replacement?

Fusion and replacement are often named in the same breath, which makes them sound alike. They are two different answers to the same problem.

The short answer

Both are surgical options for advanced, end-stage ankle arthritis, and they are not interchangeable. The Hospital for Special Surgery lists three basic options: ankle fusion (arthrodesis), ankle replacement arthroplasty, and joint-preserving ankle distraction arthroplasty.

The names tell you the first difference. Fusion is arthrodesis, and replacement is arthroplasty.

The difference that decides the choice

One difference is spelled out plainly. HSS says that patients with an active infection are not candidates for ankle replacement and are best treated with a fusion.

So the choice is not only about preference. A condition in the ankle can rule one of the two out.

Ask why fusion or why replacement

This is not a decision to make from a web page. If you have been told you are facing one of these operations, ask your surgeon why that one and what would make the other one a better fit.

For background on the condition behind the surgery, read the OrthoInfo page on arthritis of the foot and ankle and the Cleveland Clinic pages on foot and ankle arthritis and ankle replacement surgery. A PubMed Central review of cortisone injection in foot and ankle osteoarthritis covers a non-surgical option.

A calm last word

Ask your surgeon how your ankle fits each option, and why one is recommended over the others.